Conflict still surrounds MCSD legal counsel - WRBL

It's your money

Conflict still surrounds MCSD legal counsel

Posted: Updated:

A local citizen is accusing the Muscogee County school district of over-paying for legal services, compared to other districts in Georgia. But Interim Superintendent Dr. John Phillips is standing by his claim that using an outside law firm is the best, most cost-effective option.

Looking at the numbers, MCSD does spend more on legal services compared to 15 other districts in the state. In fiscal year 2012, it spent more than 702-thousand dollars compared to about 67-thousand dollars in Houston County. On average, Muscogee spends around 20-dollars per student for legal costs. In Hall County, it's only $3.42 per student.

But Dr. Phillips said the information doesn't paint an accurate depiction. "You can't just say, and divide it with the number of kids and the legal fees... again; it's a very complicated thing." He said the fees cover everything from employee claims to special needs student lawsuits and even the Chattahoochee Valley library system's legal fees.

The school district pays partners $165 hour to law firm Hatcher, Stubbs, and Attorneys at Law.

An associate fee is $115 an hour. Dr. Phillips said that is a bargain compared to market rates.

"If you're going to do a true analysis, then you have to look at every case in that school district and what the case is about. What kind of time would have to be exhausted to defend that case?" Phillips explained.

But local attorney Frank Myers disagreed. "Dr Phillips seems to think Muscogee County is somewhat... has...different problems than other school districts around the state and that's just not so."

Myers believes dividing legal expenses by the number of students is an appropriate measurement because the student body sizes are in the same ballpark as Muscogee County. He said in-house counsel can provide the same quality representation for the district.

"Kids are going without the supplies they need while lawyers are being paid twice what they deserve to be paid," he said.

But Dr. Phillips said it takes a specialized lawyer to deal with school law and those lawyers are very hard to find. "If it was something prudent and something effective you'd see more school districts doing it. There are only two school districts that have in house attorneys."

Those two counties that have in-house legal counsel are Rockdale County and Atlanta Public City Schools.

School Board Member Cathy Williams, the former board chair, said she is doing her own research before taking a stance on whether the district should move to in-house counsel.

Sydney Cameron

Sydney joined the WRBL news team in December 2011 after working as a freelance reporter in Washington, D.C. More>>

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Chattahoochee Valley “Purge” is an urban legend, police say

    Chattahoochee Valley “Purge” is an urban legend, police say

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 2:28 PM EDT2014-08-20 18:28:17 GMT
    Several police departments across the Chattahoochee Valley are reassuring concerned citizens that there will be no real-life "purge" after a social media campaign spread across Facebook on Tuesday.
    Several police departments across the Chattahoochee Valley are reassuring concerned citizens that there will be no real-life "purge" after a social media campaign spread across Facebook on Tuesday.
  • Columbus police officer attacked in Smiths Station again

    Columbus police officer attacked in Smiths Station again

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 11:29 AM EDT2014-08-20 15:29:25 GMT
    A Columbus police officer was attacked near his Smiths Station home Wednesday. This is the second time in two months this same officer was been attacked near his home.A Columbus police officer was attacked near his Smiths Station home Wednesday. This is the second time in two months this same officer was been attacked near his home.
    The same Columbus police officer was attacked near his home in Smiths Station for the second time in two months, authorities confirm to WRBL News 3.
    The same Columbus police officer was attacked near his home in Smiths Station for the second time in two months, authorities confirm to WRBL News 3.
  • May Mugshots - Northeast Tennessee

    May Mugshots - Northeast Tennessee

    Tuesday, July 8 2014 5:42 PM EDT2014-07-08 21:42:48 GMT

    The following are mugshots of individuals arrested in May by local authorities in Northeast Tennessee.

    The following are mugshots of individuals arrested in May by local authorities in Northeast Tennessee.

Powered by WorldNow

1350 13th Avenue
Columbus, GA 31901

Telephone: 706.323.3333
Fax: 706.327.6655
Email: news@wrbl.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.