Dr. Campbell: Electronic records rules could be problematic - WRBL

WNCN News

Dr. Campbell: Electronic records rules could be problematic

Posted: Updated:
RALEIGH, N.C. -

The Obama administration has clearly mandated that Electronic Medical Records (EMR) will be necessary in order to comply with federal regulations for reimbursement for both hospitals and physicians.  

The transition to EMR is an important step towards streamlining patient care – however, the current implementation of EMR is fraught with complications, workflow issues and systemwide "bugs."

At this point in the United States there are numerous EMR systems and no absolute standard which continues to make communication between different hospital systems and physicians difficult at times.  I realize that the EMR mandate has spanned more than one administration and let me state at the very outset that I am 100 percent for the implementation of an electronic medical record system.

However, I would like to see the transition be done in a step-wise, intelligent way that allows for universal portability within the U.S. Moreover, the EMR should be electronically available to all patients via smartphone and tablet download from the mysterious (and hopefully secure) "cloud."

The EMR when properly managed can provide detailed notes that are easily applied to templates for billing Medicare and Medicaid documentation (it allows MDs to correctly bill the level of service based on comparison of the patient's newly created chart note to standards for required components).  However, the time involved in documenting via EMR (especially in the transition phase in a busy practice) can be overwhelming.  Physicians and other providers are already overwhelmed with offices full of patients – longer hours, more appointments and loads of new paperwork. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) promises to add loads of newly insured sick patients to the practice workload.  Add to that a cumbersome computer system and it is likely that errors will occur.

This week in the New York Times, Abelson and Creswell report on the new Department of Justice focus on EMR fraud activities.  The Office of Inspector General (OIG) for HHS released a report on Tuesday (the second in two months) warning of the potential widespread fraud and abuse occurring as a result of EMR implementation.  The warning specifically cites a lack of oversight and safeguards in the federal government to prevent these from occurring.  The government has already spent nearly $22 billion dollars on the push for conversion from paper to EMR in the U.S.  

According to The New York Times report, the central issue with the EMR and potential fraud has to do with the lack of regulations surrounding the common practice of "copy and paste" known as "cloning."  For many physicians, the ability to cut and paste data and information from one place to another in a note or within a patient's particular chart can significantly improve efficiency and reduce the amount of time that is spent inputting redundant data into a patient's record.  Critics of this practice, including the OIG, suggest that in many cases the importation of data from note to note or chart to chart results in "overbilling" for services that were not in fact rendered.  For example, if a chart note from a follow-up visit of moderate complexity is "cloned" with data from a previous visit where the level of service was more extensive than the current visit, then charges may be filed for a level of complexity that was not, in fact, provided. The OIG statement goes on to warn that their "level of involvement in EMR cases [will] increase" and that dealing with documentation "fraud" via cloning in EMR will become a "top priority".  In a survey conducted by HHS and released in a previous report, the OIG found that very few hospitals and medical practices have any guidelines or restrictions on "cloning" notes for documentation.

In my opinion, our government has missed its mark.  Instead of carefully creating a universally acceptable and streamlined EMR that allows for responsible and efficient data entry and migration of data to subsequent encounters, federal regulators have issued another mandate without a clear vision of its implications.

As I stated earlier, I believe EMR is vital for patient information management and will ultimately help us provide more streamlined care that is evidenced based.  Unfortunately, the current EMR systems that are in place do not place a priority on ease of use, efficiency or portability.  Although I am sure that there is some intentional documentation fraud occurring, I would suggest that the majority of physicians and other providers are simply trying to "get the job done" and move on to more important patient care activities.  

EMR documentation can be slow and arduous.  During transition phases, many providers report 2-3 extra hours added to their days for documentation activities.  No physician wants to continually take a practice laptop home in order to finish entering EMR notes during family time night after night.  Cloning data is a simple way to carry over information such as medication lists, past medical histories and other information in order to improve efficiency while at the same time providing adequate documentation.  As with most things, this type of data migration is easy to abuse if physicians do not pay special attention to ensure that the migrated data is both accurate and representative of the work that was performed.

As a nation we must certainly work to prevent fraud and abuse as part of our efforts to curtail healthcare costs.  However, as we initiate reforms, we must do a much better job of anticipating issues with new technologies and work to deal with them on the front end –  if we do not, we can expect costs to continue to rise.

  • Health with Dr. CampbellMore>>

  • Dr. Campbell: New drug may be heart health game changer

    Dr. Campbell: New drug may be heart health game changer

    Monday, September 15 2014 5:00 AM EDT2014-09-15 09:00:15 GMT
    A new drug may reduce risk for death in congestive heart failure (CHF) and many scientists consider this to be a blockbuster game changing therapy.
    A new drug may reduce risk for death in congestive heart failure (CHF) and many scientists consider this to be a blockbuster game changing therapy.
  • Dr. Campbell: Respiratory illness outbreak spreading across the U.S.

    Dr. Campbell: Respiratory illness outbreak spreading across the U.S.

    Monday, September 8 2014 9:38 AM EDT2014-09-08 13:38:33 GMT
    A respiratory illness outbreak is spreading throughout the Midwest and flooding hospitals with sick children.
    A respiratory illness outbreak is spreading throughout the Midwest and flooding hospitals with sick children.
  • Dr. Campbell: Backpack safety

    Dr. Campbell: Backpack safety

    Monday, August 25 2014 5:00 AM EDT2014-08-25 09:00:15 GMT
    As Students in our area go back to school, most will purchase a new backpack in order to carry essentials to and from school. It’s important to talk about keeping kids safe ---backpacks can result in back injury, but there are strategies to help you and your student pick the right type of backpack and use it properly, avoiding serious injury.
    As Students in our area go back to school, most will purchase a new backpack in order to carry essentials to and from school. It’s important to talk about keeping kids safe ---backpacks can result in back injury, but there are strategies to help you and your student pick the right type of backpack and use it properly, avoiding serious injury.
  • Trending StoriesMore>>

  • Letter found with body of App State student, police say

    Letter found with body of App State student, police say

    Monday, September 15 2014 5:16 PM EDT2014-09-15 21:16:12 GMT
    The body of Anna Smith was discovered in a heavily wooded area in Boone.The body of Anna Smith was discovered in a heavily wooded area in Boone.
    The Boone Police Department said a letter was discovered with the body of an Appalachian State University student, indicating her death may have been a suicide.
    The Boone Police Department said a letter was discovered with the body of an Appalachian State University student, indicating her death may have been a suicide.
  • 'Party mansion' owner convicted of tax and healthcare fraud

    'Party mansion' owner convicted of tax and healthcare fraud

    Friday, September 12 2014 12:38 PM EDT2014-09-12 16:38:35 GMT
    File photoFile photo
    A former Raleigh resident, known for the wild parties held at his “party mansion” in North Raleigh, was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison for tax fraud, healthcare fraud and money laundering crimes, according to a United States Department of Justice release.
    A former Raleigh resident, known for the wild parties held at his “party mansion” in North Raleigh, was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison for tax fraud, healthcare fraud and money laundering crimes, according to a United States Department of Justice release.
  • Urban Outfitters faces backlash for controversial sweatshirt

    Urban Outfitters faces backlash for controversial sweatshirt

    Monday, September 15 2014 12:43 PM EDT2014-09-15 16:43:43 GMT
    The website of clothing outlet Urban Outfitters featured a controversial, one-of-a-kind shirt briefly Monday morning before it sold, but not before causing a stir on the Internet.
    The website of clothing outlet Urban Outfitters featured a controversial, one-of-a-kind shirt briefly Monday morning before it sold, but not before causing a stir on the Internet.
Powered by WorldNow

1350 13th Avenue
Columbus, GA 31901

Telephone: 706.323.3333
Fax: 706.327.6655
Email: news@wrbl.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.