Muscogee County school board retains no-bid deal with law firm - WRBL

Text Description

Muscogee County school board retains no-bid deal with law firm

Posted: Updated:
COLUMBUS, Ga. -

The Muscogee County school board voted Tuesday night to retain Hatcher-Stubbs as legal counsel by a 6-3 vote. The board's vote was the same as last year's vote. John Wells, Beth Harris, Naomi Buckner, Rob Varner, Pat-Hugley Green, AJ Senior voted for keeping the law firm. Shannon Smallman, Cathy Williams and Mark Cantrell voted against, hoping to open up the bid process.

The vote came after Superintendent David Lewis' recommendation to continue the six decade old relationship with the Hatcher-Stubbs law firm. One of the benchmarks Lewis said he used was a report by the Hanover Research firm, but there's been criticism about how the report obtained its information. Board member Cathy Williams and local political consultant Frank Myers have expressed their concerned with the "thoroughness" of the study. 3 experts were interviewed, and while 200 school districts were sent surveys about their legal counsel, only 26 responded. Lewis says he was not concerned about the low response rate.

“I think the fact is that we see that we have a general consensus moving forward and the sampling of the district came from throughout the country,” says Lewis.

The school district pays Hanover Research $30,000 a year for a 3-year contract. Lewis says it is in lieu of creating a research and development position. He says this saves the district money while allowing him and the board to make decisions based on analytics. Lewis says he worked with the firm in his previous school district.

“I did have an affiliation with them and we found the work to be extremely comprehensive and helpful making decisions moving forward in my former district,” says Lewis, who also mentioned the law firm representing his previous school district in Polk County, Florida had been with them for over 50 years.

Several board members expressed their opinion about what the district should do about their legal counsel at Tuesday night’s board meeting.

"We've been very satisfied with Hatcher-Stubbs, but I think its right for us to bid it out,” said Mark Cantrell. “Not allowing a bid process...that's not the American way. It's just good business to open it up."

“"I'm not going to support this,” said Cathy Williams. “I support a hybrid method, general services and specialized services."

"The best legal counsel is the one that has the most experience with school law,” said Naomi Buckner.

John Wells also weighed in, saying he is a fan of the data and analytical approach superintendent Lewis used to make a recommendation.

After about 15 minutes of discussion, the vote came and the district upheld it's current legal counsel with Hatcher-Stubbs for at least another year.

Nominate a story idea to be investigated

  • It's Your Money: Story Idea Submission

    Submit your story ideas for our next "It's Your Money" segment.

    * denotes required fields
    We're sorry, but only one entry is allowed per person.
    Thank you for your continued interest.

    Thank you for your submission. WRBL News 3 will review your idea and may get back to your with additional questions.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Motorcycle club altercation leaves 2 dead, 2 injured

    Motorcycle club altercation leaves 2 dead, 2 injured

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 7:11 AM EDT2014-09-02 11:11:25 GMT
    Two victims were shot in the chest and died. Two other people had non-life-threatening injuries and are expected to survive, said police.
    Two victims were shot in the chest and died. Two other people had non-life-threatening injuries and are expected to survive, said police.
  • New Details: Columbus man dies after being run over by own car

    New Details: Columbus man dies after being run over by own car

    Monday, September 1 2014 9:46 PM EDT2014-09-02 01:46:27 GMT
    Flowers were left at the scene where 29-year-old Anthony Williams died early Sunday morning after police say he was run over by his car.The crash happened at Chase Homes on 1st Avenue. Many residents say they could hear the crash from inside their home.“You heard the loud boom and there was a crash, when I came over here he was just laying on the ground,” said Selena Ross.Police say initially they responded to a call late Saturday night about a pedestrian being run over by a car. After talkin...
    Flowers were left at the scene where 29-year-old Anthony Williams died early Sunday morning after police say he was run over by his car.The crash happened at Chase Homes on 1st Avenue. Many residents say they could hear the crash from inside their home.“You heard the loud boom and there was a crash, when I came over here he was just laying on the ground,” said Selena Ross.Police say initially they responded to a call late Saturday night about a pedestrian being run over by a car. After talkin...
  • PHOTOS: August 2014 Mugshots

    PHOTOS: August 2014 Mugshots

    Friday, August 15 2014 3:29 PM EDT2014-08-15 19:29:55 GMT
    Mugshots from across central Alabama from August 2014.
    Mugshots from across central Alabama from August 2014.
  • Web Poll

  • Would you like to see Muscogee schools continue its relationship with the Hatcher-Stubbs law firm?

  • Thank you for participating in our poll. Here are the results so far:

    Yes
    19%
    15 votes
    No
    81%
    63 votes
  • FIRST ON 3: Lewis to recommend Muscogee schools keep law firm
  • It's Your MoneyMore>>

  • Special report: "The No-bid Deal"

    Special report: "The No-bid Deal"

    Dec 19, 2013 04:11 PM2014-09-02 16:06:21 GMT
    News 3 looks into the Muscogee County School District's 60-year, no-bid deal with the Hatcher, Stubbs Law Firm.
    News 3 looks into the Muscogee County School District's 60-year, no-bid deal with the Hatcher, Stubbs Law Firm.
  • Georgia Transportation group learns from Columbus TSPLOST

    Georgia Transportation group learns from Columbus TSPLOST

    Monday, August 18 2014 6:30 PM EDT2014-08-18 22:30:55 GMT
    List of all eight TSPLOST projectsList of all eight TSPLOST projects
    The Georgia Joint Study Committee on Critical Transportation Infrastructure Funding came to Columbus Monday to learnhow local tax dollars are being used. The group is made up of 13 state legislators and transportation gurus, and their main goal is to find out how best to save the state money while also improving mobility. Columbus is the second stop on the committee's tour of the state.The focus of the meeting was how the TSPLOSTpenny-tax is funneling $300 million intothe city's infrastructur...
    The Georgia Joint Study Committee on Critical Transportation Infrastructure Funding came to Columbus Monday to learnhow local tax dollars are being used. The group is made up of 13 state legislators and transportation gurus, and their main goal is to find out how best to save the state money while also improving mobility. Columbus is the second stop on the committee's tour of the state.The focus of the meeting was how the TSPLOSTpenny-tax is funneling $300 million intothe city's infrastructur...
  • Crude prices fall

    Crude prices fall

    Tuesday, December 10 2013 7:22 AM EST2013-12-10 12:22:00 GMT
    The cost for a barrel of oil fell last week for the sixth week in a row and remains below $95 a barrel. Although crude prices moved lower, retail gas prices remained relatively flat from the week prior.
    The cost for a barrel of oil fell last week for the sixth week in a row.
Powered by WorldNow

1350 13th Avenue
Columbus, GA 31901

Telephone: 706.323.3333
Fax: 706.327.6655
Email: news@wrbl.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.