Defense for 'Stocking Strangler' wants new trial - WRBL

Text Description

Defense for 'Stocking Strangler' wants new trial

Posted: Updated:
Gary smiled at his wife as he walked into court Monday Gary smiled at his wife as he walked into court Monday
COLUMBUS, Ga. - Monday defense attorneys began their pursuit of a retrial for Carlton Gary, the man sentenced to death for killing women in their Columbus homes in the 1970's.

It has been 36 years since a serial killer struck fear into the hearts of many in Columbus. Carlton Gary was convicted of three of the stranglings in 1986, but now his defense team says they can prove he's innocent.

Gary walked into the courtroom blowing a kiss to his wife and daughter and smiling. Attorney Jack Martin spent hours working to convince Judge Frank Jordan to retry the case based on three main points:
  • A footprint left at one of the scenes that is a different size than Gary's
  • A bite mark found on one of the victims that the defense claims is not a forensic match to Gary
  • Contaminated DNA testing at the GBI crime lab
District Attorney Julia Slater argued that there was no truly new evidence, but Judge Jordan allowed the defense to present its witnesses, who included Dr. Greg Hampikian, a DNA expert who worked on the Amanda Knox trial, among many others. He said the testing done on the old seminal evidence was not analyzed with the most advanced technology, and that after retesting, two separate spots of semen found on the clothing of victim Gertrude Miller were not a genetic match to Carlton Gary.

Martin asked Hampikian, "To a reasonable degree of scientific certainty based on DNA, the individual who left sperm on Ms. Miller's clothing at the time of her rape was not Mr. Gary?"

"The sperm on the stains is not from Mr. Gary," Hampikian responded. "That's what I would say."

Dr. Hampikian also said that a new analysis of semen left on Martha Thurmond's body didn't match Gary either.

Gary's wife Debra is optimistic about getting a new trial. "It's a good thing," she says. "This is what we've wanted ever since they wrongly arrested, convicted my husband of it. All we wanted was to have a fair opportunity to present the truth."

She adds that her husband remains in good spirits despite the the decades behind bars. She says, "For him it's probably frustrating for him to sit up and hear somebody say things that you know are not true and not be able to say anything about it, but he's good."

Attorneys expect the hearing to last at least through Wednesday.

Jessi Mitchell

Jessi joined the WRBL news team in October 2012 after working as a freelance production assistant for MTV Networks in Los Angeles.
More>>

James Brierton

James joined WRBL News 3 with experience from CNN, NBC News and his own hyper-local news site. He manages the WRBL News 3 Web desk. More>>

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • WRBL Poll: Georgia governor, senate races remain tight

    WRBL Poll: Georgia governor, senate races remain tight

    Sep 02, 2014 04:41 PM2014-09-02 21:47:57 GMT
    New WRBL News 3 / Ledger-Enquirer / PMB Broadcasting poll carried out by GaPundit.com show Georgia governor and senate race remains neck and neck ahead of November election.New WRBL News 3 / Ledger-Enquirer / PMB Broadcasting poll carried out by GaPundit.com show Georgia governor and senate race remains neck and neck ahead of November election.
    New statewide Georgia poll finds the race between Nathan Deal and Jason Carter for governor - and the race between David Perdue and Michelle Nunn for U.S. Senate - remain highly competitive.
    New statewide Georgia poll finds the race between Nathan Deal and Jason Carter for governor - and the race between David Perdue and Michelle Nunn for U.S. Senate - remain highly competitive.
  • PHOTOS: Phenix City gas station robbed at gunpoint

    PHOTOS: Phenix City gas station robbed at gunpoint

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 11:23 AM EDT2014-09-02 15:23:31 GMT
    Surveillance image show an armed man robbing a Phenix City gas station early Monday morning.Surveillance image show an armed man robbing a Phenix City gas station early Monday morning.
    Phenix City police release images of a man robbing a gas station at gunpoint early Monday morning.
    Phenix City police release images of a man robbing a gas station at gunpoint early Monday morning.
  • PHOTOS: August 2014 Mugshots

    PHOTOS: August 2014 Mugshots

    Friday, August 15 2014 3:29 PM EDT2014-08-15 19:29:55 GMT
    Mugshots from across central Alabama from August 2014.
    Mugshots from across central Alabama from August 2014.
  • Crime WatchMore>>

  • PHOTOS: Phenix City gas station robbed at gunpoint

    PHOTOS: Phenix City gas station robbed at gunpoint

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 11:23 AM EDT2014-09-02 15:23:31 GMT
    Surveillance image show an armed man robbing a Phenix City gas station early Monday morning.Surveillance image show an armed man robbing a Phenix City gas station early Monday morning.
    Phenix City police release images of a man robbing a gas station at gunpoint early Monday morning.
    Phenix City police release images of a man robbing a gas station at gunpoint early Monday morning.
  • Woman robbed of $700 at knifepoint in Columbus bank parking lot, report says

    Woman robbed of $700 at knifepoint in Columbus bank parking lot, report says

    Saturday, August 30 2014 11:11 PM EDT2014-08-31 03:11:34 GMT
    Two men held a 50-year-old woman at knife point and took hundreds of dollars from her in a bank parking lot Friday, according to a police report.The woman told police the attack happened after she withdrew $700 from the Wells Fargo ATM on 13th Street. She says it happened around 5:30 in the afternoon.“That is very surprising, especially in broad daylight. It's just getting outrageous these days,” said Roy Robertson, who was withdrawing money from the ATM on Saturday.The woman told News 3 she ...
    Two men held a 50-year-old woman at knife point and took hundreds of dollars from her in a bank parking lot Friday, according to a police report.The woman told police the attack happened after she withdrew $700 from the Wells Fargo ATM on 13th Street. She says it happened around 5:30 in the afternoon.“That is very surprising, especially in broad daylight. It's just getting outrageous these days,” said Roy Robertson, who was withdrawing money from the ATM on Saturday.The woman told News 3 she ...
  • Bloody details revealed in Columbus murder suspect’s court hearing

    Bloody details revealed in Columbus murder suspect’s court hearing

    Saturday, August 30 2014 12:01 AM EDT2014-08-30 04:01:33 GMT
    Police say the man accused of killing a Columbus woman and her baby was covered with blood when police pulled him over hours after the bodies were found.Brandon Conner had his first court hearing on Friday. Detectives testified on how they connected Conner, 35, to the murders.The remains of Rosella Mitchell and her son Dylan Conner were found in a home on Winifred Lane after a fire last Thursday. Officials say Mitchell was stabbed with a knife multiple times before the fire.Police say several...
    Police say the man accused of killing a Columbus woman and her baby was covered with blood when police pulled him over hours after the bodies were found.Brandon Conner had his first court hearing on Friday. Detectives testified on how they connected Conner, 35, to the murders.The remains of Rosella Mitchell and her son Dylan Conner were found in a home on Winifred Lane after a fire last Thursday. Officials say Mitchell was stabbed with a knife multiple times before the fire.Police say several...
Powered by WorldNow

1350 13th Avenue
Columbus, GA 31901

Telephone: 706.323.3333
Fax: 706.327.6655
Email: news@wrbl.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.